The following is Dr. Garber's brief and selected
FAQ with links regarding ADD and ADHD.
|
"Where
can I learn more about ADD and ADHD?"
|
Healthyparent.com
provides selected links regarding ADD and ADHD. To view these links, click
. The American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical
Manual (4th Edition), known as DSM IV, offers the definitive diagnostic
criteria for this and other such labels.
|
Top of page
|
|
"Are there definitive tests to determine if
I have/my child has
ADD or ADHD?"
|
No.
An x-ray is (usually) a definitive test of a bone's integrity.
By contrast, ADHD and ADD can only be diagnosed on the basis of some combination
of:
(1)
professional observation across two or more settings [classroom, home and
office, for example],
(2) standardized and valid reporting measures completed
by spouse, parents, teachers [Connors' Rating Scales, for example], and
(3) reference to standardized and valid quantitative measures
of attention and concentration, such as those available using the Wechsler
intelligence tests [the WISC III, for example].
|
Top of page
|
|
"Can ADHD or ADD be diagnosed in a single office visit?"
|
Yes.
Any diagnosis can be offered under any circumstances. Will
that diagnosis be valid and accurate? Particularly when attention difficulties
are at issue, the more data available and the more independent sources considered
the more accurate the diagnosis is likely to be.
|
Top of page
|
|
"Can
other diagnoses and life circumstances be mistakenly diagnosed as
ADHD or ADD?"
|
Easily
and often.
These diagnoses are offered too often and too quickly in
contemporary society. Many other diagnoses and situations can and often are
mistakenly called ADHD and ADD, including depression and anxiety, adjustment
to trauma, learning disabilities and physical health problems including hearing
and vision deficits.
Read
about ADD/ADHD "Look-alikes"
|
Top of page
|
"How
can I determine if I have/my child has ADHD or ADD
with any certainty?"
|
Because
other conditions and circumstances are so easily and often mikstaken for
ADHD and ADD, the first step is to rule these out. This is not a quick process
and is likely to require time, money and assertiveness, particularly if
the concern is about a child. Try these steps:
1. Get a comprehensive physical examination from your primary care physician.
Request thorough blood work (sorry kids: some needles are involved) including
consideration of thyroid dysfunction, blood sugar (glucose) levels and iron.
2. Get a thorough vision and hearing exam. Schools
and primary care physicians often offer brief screenings of both hearing
and sight, but when any question persists, visit an audiologist and an opthamologist
independently.
3. Beware environmental contributors! Something
as commonplace as a furnace leaking carbon monozide can cause symptoms resembling
ADD/ADHD and/or depression. In sufficient quantities or accumulated exposure,
carbon monozide can cause lasting impairment or death.
4. Complete a cognitive screening battery. This includes
an intelligence (for example: WISC-III) and an achievement (for example:
Woodcock-Johnson) test. The school district may be able to do this for you
at no cost upon your written request to the superintendant's office. Although
absolute IQ numbers may be of interest, these tests in combination help to
understand whether you are fulfilling your intellectual potential. When
achievement is significantly different than IQ, questions about learning differences
can be considered.
5. Complete an outpatient evaluation with a qualified
child-centered mental health professional. This will typically include interviews,
observations, completion of standardized report forms (the Connors
forms, for example) and a synthesis of all of the data available to reach
a preliminary diagnosis and recommendation for assistance.
|
Top of page
|
"How
does Dr. Garber evaluate ADHD and ADD?"
|
Dr. Garber
is very conservative in reaching the ADHD and ADD diagnosis. The typical
diagnostic procedure for children requires the four steps above. In addition,
Dr Garber typically requests:
1.
An initial 90 minute history and background interview with all co-parents.
(2. In some circumstances the opportunity to observe the child unannounced
in the classroom is a very effective assessment tool.)
3. Two individual interviews in the office with the child.
4. A family observation in the office.
5. Collection of colateral data (grade reports, testing, Connors' report
forms...).
6. Feedback to the parents regarding diagnostic formulation and recommendations
for continuing treatment, changes at home and/or in school, and/or for medication
consultation.
|
Top of page
|
"Should
I consider medication?"
|
Dr. Garber
takes a very conservative position in referring for medication consultation.
Assuming that there is no concern for any person's immediate health or safety,
you might consider the process of medication consultation in this way:
1. Get educated: Long before the
need becomes critical, learn as much as you can about the medications that
might be considered. Generally, the medications of choice are some formulation
of methylphenidate. Search the internet. Sit down with the local pharmacist.
Schedule a meeting with your physician.
2. Be practical: The science of medication (called
psychopharmacology) is still young. There is no certainty that the first
prescription will be the right medication or the right dosage. Expect to experiment
at the prescribing physician's direction over time until you've got it right.
That can take weeks. Also consider that getting in to see the pediatrician
or psychiatrist of choice can take weeks. As a practical matter, this means
that you should probably call to schedule that appointment at least eight
to twelve weeks in advance. Don't wait for a crisis!
3. How do you know when to call? Consider two factors:
|
DISTRESS
(How much anger/sadness/confusion/upset
you feel inside?)
(none) 0....1....2...3...4....5....6...7...8...9....10
(catastrophic!)
DYSFUNCTION
(To what degree is your day-today
functioning impaired?)
(none) 0....1....2...3...4....5....6...7...8...9....10
(catastrophic!)
|
When
either number is 7 or greater OR when the combination of the two is 10 or
greater, its very likely time to act.
Remember:
Prompt relief from the symptoms of ADHD and ADD (as can sometimes be achieved
with medication) is important both in order to improve academic or occupational
performance and in order to minimize the associated experiences of anxiety
and depression (read on below....).
|
Top of page
|
|
"Can ADHD or ADD
be accompanied by other difficulties?"
|
Yes.
For reasons that are not well understood, ADD and ADHD
are often accompanied by:
(1)
learning disabilities
or
(2) sensory defensiveness
and/or
(3) social awkwardness sometimes associated with Asperger's
Syndrome or Non-Verbal Learning Disabilities
There is no
necessary relationship between ADD or ADHD and intelligence.
Undiagnosed and untreated, ADD and ADHD often cause an
individual to commonly experience rejection, criticism and failure, experiences
that can result in secondary anxiety and depression
|
Top of page
|
"Why
might a
stimulant medication help a
hyperactive and distractable
person?"
|
Stimulant
medications (for example Ritalin®,
Concerta®, Adderol®,
Focalin®, each of which is a brand name
formulation of a compound called methylphenidate) are among the most
commonly prescribed medications for ADD and ADHD. Physicians usually describe
these substances as relatively benign and short-lived in a person's body.
Still, these are medications and therefore have some risk of at least psychological
addiction, abuse and overdose. See your prescribing physician and/or your
pharmacist about these concerns.
In theory, imagine that everybody seeks to maintain an
optimal level of total stimulation (like filling a cup to the top). Total
stimulation is a combination of two substances (like oil and water combining
to fill the cup). One part is arousal, the stimulation we experience from
within (including anxiety and physical discomfort). The other part is stimulation,
the relative value of sensory input we receive from the world around us
(sight, sound, texture, smell....). The theory is that ADD and ADHD individuals
have just a drip of arousal in the bottom of their cups, therefore needing
a constant and large dose of sensory input to reach optimal arousal, creating
distractibility and overactivity. Stimulants serve to increase arousal,
filling the cup more and decreasing the need for stimulation from the world,
thus decreasing activity level and distractibility.
[Its interesting in this theory to imagine that autism
may be the opposite: Individuals with too much arousal who cannot tolerate
even a drop of stimulation from the world around them.]
|
Top of page
|
|
"What
can be done to help a student with ADD or ADHD achieve better in school?"
|
Specific
strategies to assist with education are offered
HERE
In order to institute these kinds of interventions, you
may need to learn more about the federal Individuals with Disabilities in
Education Act (IDEA 97), about Indivual Education Plans (IEPs) and 504 plans.
The single best readable reference to these matters can be found
. In New Hampshire, contact the Parent
Information Center 603.224.7005.
|
Top of page
|
|
"How
can
ADD and ADHD
and parental conflict, separation and divorce interact?"
|
Click HERE
to read Dr. Garber's article on this subject.
|
Top of page
|